The Lady in Question (1940) Charles Vidor


The Lady in Question (1940) Charles Vidor

If you thought Gilda (1946) was the first time Glenn Ford and Rita Hayworth worked together onscreen, you’d be wrong. The Lady in Question was the first of five films they’d make together (the other three being The Loves of Carmen [1948], Affair in Trinidad [1952] and The Money Trap [1965]). Charles Vidor, of course, also directed Ford and Hayworth in Gilda.


The Lady in Question is a remake of the 1937 French comedy Gribouille (Heart of Paris or The Meddler) directed by Marc Allégret and featuring Michèle Morgan in her first major screen appearance. The Lady in Question takes place in Paris where a good-natured bicycle shop owner named Andre Morestan (Brian Aherne, left) is obsessed with the pride that comes from exercising his civic responsibility as a man called to jury duty. When the call comes, Morestan becomes obsessed with the case: a young woman named Natalie Roguin (Rita Hayworth) is accused of murdering her lover.


It’s not much of a spoiler to tell you that Natalie is acquitted. Soon afterward, Morestan offers Natalie a job at his shop as well as room and board in his house, but no one in his family knows Natalie as an accused murderer. Morestan has told them all that she’s the daughter of one of his former classmates.


His intentions are honorable and good, yet there’s quite a few people at home Morestan will have to keep in the dark: his wife (Irene Rich), son Pierre (Glenn Ford), daughter François (Evelyn Keyes), her fiancé (Edward Norris), as well as the locals who frequent his shop. Plus Natalie and Pierre seem to be growing quite fond of each other. Hmmm….


Aherne is quite charming as the shop owner and the film is an enjoyable venture, but it’s difficult to combine courtroom drama with light comedy; the two just don’t mix well. The comedic touches win out, but the courtroom scenes are not without intensity. There’s a nice scene as the jury deliberates, a scene that reminds me of a larger moment from 12 Angry Men, which came about 17 years later. (One of the best lines in the film comes from one of the jurors talking about Natalie: “She comes from a theatrical family and you know what that means!”)


Ford and Hayworth here are nothing like you’ll see them in Gilda. Or maybe it’s better to think of them as young idealists in The Lady in Question who’ve become jaded and wise to the ways of the world by the time Gilda rolls around. It’s a nice, light afternoon venture that might even become one of your favorite “comfort” movies. The film is available on DVD from the Sony Choice Collection.


Photos: Mike’s Take on the Movies, Rare Film, TCM, IMDB

4 thoughts on “The Lady in Question (1940) Charles Vidor

  1. Pingback: Movies Watched in February 2017 Part III | Journeys in Darkness and Light

  2. Ford looks like he’s just out of high school, doesn’t he?
    Aherne’s career goes all the way back to the silent era, but you may also have seen him on a few TV shows. I also saw him in THE LOCKET and I CONFESS. I also want to see him in more.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I didn’t know Rita Hayworth and Glenn Ford had worked together before “Gilda”. And speaking of Glenn Ford, he looks so young here I almost didn’t recognize him!

    I need to see this. I’m not that familiar with Brian Aherne’s work. I saw him in one film and became an instant fan. I bet he’s fabulous here.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s