The Best of 2017: Silent Movies

The Best of 2017Silent Movies

With apologies to my friend Movies Silently, I must confess that silent movies are still quite a blindspot for me. I’m almost never disappointed when I watch silent films, but I think it’s getting myself in the right frame of mind to watch them that keeps me from watching more often. Just know that it’s something I’m still working on… So here are the silent films I most enjoyed in 2017:


A Trip to the Moon (1902) Georges Méliès
Flicker Alley Blu-ray (0:15)

When Flicker Alley announced months ago that its Blu-ray release of A Trip to the Moon (1902) was going out of print and that they were offering it at a discount, I jumped on it fast. (The discount has since expired, but you can still get the Blu-ray.)

Anyone who loves and appreciates film already knows what an important place A Trip to the Moon holds in cinematic history, so I’m not going to belabor the point here. The work is only 15 minutes long, but it is amazing for what it does, how it does it and how it continues to influence films over 100 years later. For modern audiences watching the film who may not “get it” or may dismiss it as a charming relic from ancient history, I urge them to watch the documentary also included on the Blu-ray, The Extraordinary Voyage (2011) which not only explores the life of Georges Méliès, creator of A Trip to the Moon, but also details the process and importance of film restoration better than any other documentary I’ve seen. If you love movies, this is a must-own, not only for yourself, but also to show others.


Napoléon (1927) Abel Gance
BFI Blu-ray (Region B) (5:32)

I’m not even going to try to expound on this landmark film. The first 15 minutes alone will knock you into the middle of next week and it just gets more impressive as you watch for over five more hours, a stretch of time that feels more like 15 minutes. I honestly wouldn’t know where to start talking about this monumental masterwork. Maybe after I’ve seen it again I’ll be able to give this a full review. I’ll just say that you simply must see it.

Currently the film is available only through a release from BFI, a Region B release that requires a region-free Blu-ray player. There are rumors that a U.S. release is coming, but some of those same rumors claim that the film may look and will certainly sound different (with a different soundtrack). Silent film historian Kevin Brownlow should be given an award (or several) for spending the last 50 years of his life piecing together and restoring the film. See it and you’ll understand why. Buying this Blu-ray is reason enough to own a region-free Blu-ray player. Seriously.


Man with a Movie Camera (1929) Dziga Vertov
FilmStruck (1:08)

Narrative feature? Documentary? Experiment? Just how do you describe Man with a Movie Camera? The film contains no professional actors and there probably wasn’t a real “script” in the way we normally think of scripts. The film instead captures various images from urban life in the Soviet cities of Kiev, Kharkov, Moscow and Odessa. We see people working, playing, and most interestingly, confronting various types of machinery, both simple and industrial. Yet this is no quaint look back at a simpler time. Vertov uses a variety of (then) avant-garde styles and techniques such as slow motion, fast motion, double exposure, jump cuts, Dutch angles, split screen, and more. (The version I saw on FilmStruck features original music composed and performed by The Alloy Orchestra. If you get a chance, see this version.)

The film is important for showing audiences then (and reminding us now) of where film can go, a reminder that rules and limits are made to be broken, even shattered. All the techniques in the film have become rather commonplace and seeing the film with 21st century eyes dilutes its power somewhat, but seeing it for the first time in 1929 (or even 1939, 1949, etc.) must have been a mind-blower. Even now, close to 90 years later, it’s still a mind-blower.

Intimate Movie Scene with Greta Garbo and John Gilbert

Flesh and the Devil (1926) Clarence Brown
DVD – library (1:53)

Wonderful silent film about two boyhood friends (Lars Hanson and John Gilbert) who fall for the same woman (Greta Garbo). Extraordinary on many levels, the film is beautifully photographed by William H. Daniels and seems so much more modern than its 1926 time period suggests. Direction, acting, everything is superb, and of course there’s Garbo. Flesh and the Devil, along with Queen Christina (1933), was part of our Greta Garbo Double Feature at the Severna Park Library recently.


The Phantom of the Opera (1925) Rupert Julian
DVD – library (1:41)

Quite possibly the greatest version of the story with a show-stealing performance by the masterful Lon Chaney, Sr. in the title role. I’m embarrassed to say that this is the first time I’ve seen the film, part of my Blindspot series from last year that I’m just now getting around to watching.


The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog (1927) Alfred Hitchcock
Filmstruck (1:31)

Although I consider myself a big fan, this is the first silent film I’ve seen from Alfred Hitchcock (which probably disqualifies me as a “big fan”). Based on the Marie Belloc Lowndes novel The Lodger and the play Who Is He?, The Lodger is really a Jack the Ripper story that stands as an early example of several emerging Hitchcock themes, primarily that of the innocent man accused. It’s great fun to watch the interesting camera angles and lighting, clearly influenced by German filmmakers. A good one, recently released on Blu-ray from Criterion.


The Blot (1921) Lois Weber
Milestone DVD (1:31)

It’s a shame that (1) so few people watch silent films and (2) that fewer still know of the legacy of Lois Weber, one of most important American directors who was also an actress, screenwriter, producer and much more. The Blot is possibly her most seen film, a social drama about Amelia, a young librarian (Claire Windsor, right) whose father (Philip Hubbard) is a college professor struggling to make ends meet. Amelia catches the attention of a spoiled rich college student in her father’s class, a boy named Phil West (a young Louis Calhern, left), as well as an equally poor young preacher. The wealthy immigrant family next door looks down upon Amelia and her family and Weber provides some potent social commentary while delivering an expertly produced narrative, one that clearly shows her talent and influence.


Sherlock Jr. (1924) Buster Keaton, William Goodrich (Roscoe Arbuckle, uncredited)
Kino Lorber, The Buster Keaton Collection Blu-ray (0:45)

This undisputed classic finds Keaton as a movie projectionist who falls asleep on the job while showing a detective movie, projecting himself into the film as a master detective. A wonderful film. Watch more Keaton.

That’s it for the best silents of 2017. Recommendations are welcome!

5 thoughts on “The Best of 2017: Silent Movies

  1. Ah, INTOLERANCE… I feel like watching that is going to be a chore, but I really need to do it this year. NAPOLEON is a real treasure. Wish I could see it on the big screen. Eager to hear your thoughts when you see it (either on the large or small screen).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved, LOVED Man with a Movie Camera. (Alas, I lent my copy to a friend and now they really love it… I think I’ll have to buy a replacement copy.)

    I have made it a goal to watch all of “Intolerance” in 2018. I’m intrigued by your review of “Napoleon”, and it’s length. If I come across it, I will definitely set aside a day to watch it.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Hope you like them….actually I had time to go to my Letterboxd list (always a lifesaver!) and here are a few more that are worth the time.

    Piccadilly with Anna May Wong
    Battleship Potemkin
    Noah’s Ark-It’s a bit lumbering but an impressive achievement for its time
    La Roue
    The Phantom Carriage
    Different from the Others
    The Grim Game-This was only average but it’s a rare chance to see Harry Houdini in action.

    I’ve seen both Intolerance and Birth of a Nation and while they are vital to film knowledge and impressive in that way I have to be honest and say I struggled through them. Same goes for Way Down East and Broken Blossoms.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Thanks, Joel – Lots of great recommendations! I’ve actually seen none of Joan Crawford’s silent work, so I’m really looking forward to exploring those films. I have seen a few of the other films you mentioned but have missed out (so far) on Wings, The Crowd, and a few others. I certainly want to explore much, much more Chaney work. Thanks!


  5. I’ve seen all but the Keaton, silent comedy doesn’t do much for me, and they all were at least interesting.

    Man with a Movie Camera was cool for what it was but as a narrative entertainment not so much.

    Napoleon and Phantom of the Opera are awesome achievements considering the age of the films. That color sequence in Phantom is incredible.

    Garbo’s silents are a very mixed bag with the only constant her incredible star power shining through even the most purple of melodramas. Flesh and the Devil is a bit much in the plot department but she and Gilbert share a fantastic electricity between them.

    I am also deficient in my silent film viewing though I try to expand it when something that sounds interesting is running on TCM or I like one of the performers. But I have managed to see quite a few good ones.

    A performer who is fascinating to watch in silents is Joan Crawford because you can see her evolve from first just another player to a striking girl with a strong presence to a personality that pulls the camera’s attention without even trying. There are several of her silents that I haven’t seen and a few are lost but the ones that are extant and available, even the tossed together ones, are worth watching for the aspect of her emergence. She is in the only silent I’ve watched more than once-The Unknown. What a wild ride that film is, she’s nearly unrecognizable but still registers and Lon Chaney is riveting as a very conflicted guy willing to go to mind boggling extremes because of his love for her.

    Not sure what you’ve seen but outside of essentials like Wings, The Crowd, Sunrise and Pandora’s Box I’d recommend the following.

    The Last Command, Diary of a Lost Girl and The Big Parade were the three other than The Unknown that I liked best but Strike, The Winning of Barbara Worth, Downhill, The Ring, The Man Who Laughs, Foolish Wives, Faust, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, The Last Laugh, Greed, Laugh Clown Laugh (really any Chaney film except the wretched Mr. Wu are worth catching), The Wind and Orphans of the Storm are decent films.

    Also any Douglas Fairbanks adventure flick is usually fun and the place which I recommend to anyone who is unfamiliar with silents as a good start since their reliance on movement over dialogue cards make them more accessible.

    However someone whose allure escapes me is Mary Pickford. I can understand how she was popular in her day but her mostly puerile antics leave me cold. I can’t honestly say I’ve seen one movie of hers that I really liked though her last film-Secrets wasn’t awful nor was she bad in it something that can’t be said for her other sound films.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s